It’s a question almost every car owner ponders at some point: “Is it cheaper to change your own oil?” It seems like every time we take our car in for an oil change, the bill raises the same question. Many people have a friend or family member who swears by DIY oil changes, insisting they’re simple and anyone can learn.
The truth is that most people can change their oil, and it will save money in the long run. But there’s an initial investment in tools and supplies to get started. If you’re considering taking the plunge and learning how to change your own oil, weigh the potential cost savings against a few other factors.
Table of Contents
Is it Cost-Effective? A Balancing Act
On the surface, a DIY oil change appears undeniably cheaper. You eliminate labor costs, often the bulk of a professional change’s price. However, factor in the initial investment in tools like an oil filter wrench, drain pan, and jack stands. Consider the cost of the oil and filter you choose, aiming for quality while staying within your budget. Remember, responsibly disposing of used oil also incurs a cost.
While calculating these expenses, remember to value your time. If a professional service takes an hour, but your DIY attempt stretches to three, the convenience factor might outweigh the monetary savings.
What are the tools that you might need for oil change?
If you’re ready to learn how to change your oil yourself, a few resources are available. You can ask a knowledgeable friend or relative to show you the ropes or watch one of the many YouTube tutorials available. Once you’re familiar with the process, consider these factors before you dive in:
Initial investment vs. long-term savings:
Jack: A quality jack, essential for safely raising your car, can cost around $250. Depending on your perspective, this might be worth it. If you’re mechanically inclined, you’ll use the jack for oil changes, but it can also come in handy for other maintenance and repairs.
Jack stands for Safety first! You don’t want to rely solely on the jack to hold your car while you work underneath. Jack stands, typically around $35, provide crucial stability.
Oil drain pan: You’ll need a pan to catch the old oil as it drains from your engine. These reusable pans cost about $20.
Miscellaneous items: Rubber gloves, towels, and a funnel are other items you’ll likely need. They’re inexpensive, but factor them into your budget.
How much does it cost to do an oil change on your own?
Do it yourself (DIY):
- Oil & filter: $20-$50 (depending on quality and car requirements)
- Tools: $30-$100 (initial investment, reusable across changes)
- Disposal fees: $5-$10 (varies by location)
- Total: $55-$160 (first change, reduces with reuse of tools)
Dealership: $70-$150 (can vary widely based on dealership, oil type, additional services)
How long does it take for DIY and at the dealership?
DIY: 30-60 minutes (experienced), longer for beginners
Dealership: 1-2 hours (waiting time included)
Do I have the knowledge to do an oil change?
Before diving in:
- Ensure you possess the necessary knowledge and skills.
- Consult your car’s manual for specific instructions and safety precautions.
- Familiarize yourself with the location of the drain plug, oil filter, and proper disposal procedures for used oil and the filter. If you need clarification on any step, err on the side of caution and seek professional help.
What are the things you must consider before an oil change?
Before you commit to DIY oil changes, consider these additional factors:
- Satisfaction vs. excitement: Completing a DIY oil change might bring satisfaction from saving money, but it may not have the same “wow” factor as other DIY projects like home improvement.
- Potential mistakes: During an oil change, mistakes could lead to costly repairs. Using the wrong oil, improperly installing the filter, or buying incorrect parts can all create problems.
- Messiness: Let’s face it: oil changes are messy. No matter how careful you are, you’ll likely make a mess every time.
- Safety concerns: Working under a car has inherent risks, including the possibility of the car falling on you. Additionally, exposure to used oil can harm you, your pets, and the environment.
Is it Cheaper to Change Your Own Oil?
Now that you understand the upfront costs of DIY oil changes let’s compare them to typical garage prices. Remember, the exact cost depends on the specific oil and filter you choose and where you buy them.
However, a typical garage oil change might cost around $50-$75, while the oil and filter for a DIY change might cost around $25-$40. You could save $15-$35 per oil change by doing it yourself.
What are the pros and cons of DIY and Dealerships?
While cost-savings might not be immediate, DIY oil changes offer distinct advantages; here are some pros and cons:
DIY:
Pros:
- Potentially cheaper: Especially after initial tool investment
- Control over quality: Choose specific oil and filter brands
- Learn a valuable skill: Gain self-reliance and car knowledge
- Satisfaction of accomplishment: Feeling good about doing it yourself
Cons:
- Time commitment: Requires dedicating time to the job
- Potential mess: Spills and drips can happen, and disposal adds hassle
- Risk of error: Improper draining or tightening can damage the car
- Not for everyone: Not comfortable with mechanics or messy tasks
Dealership:
Pros:
- Convenience: Quick and easy, no mess on your hands
- Professional expertise: Trained technicians ensure proper procedure
- Potential warranties: Some dealerships offer warranties on oil changes
- Additional services May include fluid top-offs and inspections
Cons:
- Cost: Usually more expensive than DIY
- Limited control: Less choice over oil brand and service details
- Potential upselling: Risk of being recommended unnecessary services
- Waiting time: Inconvenience of scheduling and waiting at the shop
The Verdict
Whether changing your oil is cheaper depends on several factors. If you’re cost-conscious, handy, and have the time, DIY can save you money in the long run. However, the dealership route might be better if convenience and mess-free service are priorities. Ultimately, the choice comes down to your personal preferences and priorities.
Relevant:
Are Oil Changes Covered Under Warranty?
How To Change Oil Pressure Sensor?
How Long After Oil Change Does the Light Come On?
How Long Does Oil Last in a Car Not Driven?
FAQs
Where can I dispose of used oil?
Many auto parts stores and quick lube shops will accept used oil for recycling. You can also check with your local municipality for hazardous waste disposal guidelines.
What are the environmental implications of DIY oil changes?
Improper disposal of used oil can harm the environment. Professional service providers ensure environmentally responsible disposal according to EPA regulations.
What if I make a mistake during a DIY oil change?
Mistakes can lead to costly repairs. If you’re unsure about your mechanical skills, it’s safer and potentially more cost-effective to seek professional help.
Do you really save money doing your own oil change?
It depends. Upfront, yes, you can save $25-$75 compared to dealership prices. But factor in:
– Initial tool investment: Wrenches, drain pan, etc., cost $30-$100 initially.
– Disposal fees: Varies by location, but can add $5-$10.
– Your time: 30-60 minutes for experienced DIYers, longer for beginners.
Long-term savings depend on how often you change your oil and choose tools wisely. Reusable tools make DIY more attractive.
What tools do I need for a DIY oil change?
Basic tools include an oil pan, funnel, wrenches, pliers, and jack/ramps. Consult your car’s manual for specific requirements.
Is it challenging to change my own oil?
With the proper knowledge and preparation, it’s manageable. Consult your car’s manual and online resources for detailed instructions and safety precautions.
How can I save money on oil changes?
DIY if comfortable: Consider the above factors to see if it makes sense.
Compare dealership prices: Look for promotions or coupons.
Choose synthetic oil: It lasts longer, reducing change frequency (check your car’s manual).
Buy oil and filters in bulk: When prices are low, consider stocking up responsibly.
Ask about “quick lube” options: Some offer lower prices than full-service dealerships.
What are the benefits of changing your own oil?
Potential cost savings: As mentioned above, if you’re handy and have time.
Control over quality: Choose specific oil and filter brands for your car’s needs.
Learning a valuable skill: Gain self-reliance and car knowledge.
Satisfaction of accomplishment: Feel good about doing it yourself.
